Why Middle-Market Leaders Should Be Exploring Insurance Captives in 2026

A look down the street from our Steamboat Springs location - one of our favorite winter views

For many middle-market companies ($10M–$100M in revenue), insurance has historically been treated as a fixed expense — something to negotiate once a year and move on.

That approach is quickly becoming outdated.

As premiums rise, underwriting tightens, and risk becomes more closely tied to enterprise value, forward-thinking leadership teams are asking a different question:

Should we continue renting risk from the insurance market — or is it time to own part of it?

This is where insurance captives enter the conversation.

What Is an Insurance Captive (In Plain English)?

An insurance captive is a licensed insurance company owned by your business (or a group of businesses) that allows you to insure certain risks yourself while still accessing the commercial market where it makes sense.

Think of it as moving from being a passive buyer of insurance to becoming an active risk owner and strategist.

Why Captives Are Gaining Momentum in the Middle Market

Historically, captives were reserved for Fortune 500 companies. That is no longer the case.

Improved structures, better regulatory frameworks, and rising insurance volatility have made captives increasingly viable for middle-market organizations.

Leadership teams are exploring captives because they can:

·       Reduce long-term insurance spend

·       Retain underwriting profit instead of giving it away

·       Gain control over claims and coverage design

·       Improve cash flow predictability

·       Create risk transparency at the executive and Board level

In short: captives turn insurance from a sunk cost into a financial and strategic asset.

The Strategic Advantage Most Leaders Miss

The biggest benefit of a captive is not just cost savings.

It’s control.

Companies with captives gain the ability to:

·       Align insurance strategy with business growth

·       Design coverage around real operational risk

·       Avoid sudden market swings

·       Improve risk discipline across the organization

This matters more than ever as Boards, lenders, and investors increasingly scrutinize risk management maturity.

Is Your Company a Good Candidate?

Not every organization is ready for a captive — and that’s okay.

However, companies often qualify when they have:

·       Stable revenues and predictable cash flow

·       Annual insurance spend typically above $250K–$500K

·       Strong safety or risk management culture

·       Leadership interest in long-term strategy

·       Desire to move beyond reactive renewals

The key is not company size alone — it’s risk maturity and leadership mindset.

The Biggest Mistake Companies Make

The most common mistake is viewing a captive as a “tax play” or short-term premium reduction tactic.

Successful captives are built around:

·       Long-term strategy

·       Governance discipline

·       Risk alignment

·       Executive ownership

When captives are treated as financial engineering alone, they fail.

When treated as strategic infrastructure, they create lasting value.

What Comes Next

As we move into 2026, more middle-market companies will face a simple reality:

Traditional insurance alone will not provide the stability, control, or predictability leadership teams want.

Captives won’t be the answer for everyone — but for the right companies, they can be transformational.

The real question is not whether captives are “worth it.”

The question is:

Are you willing to keep giving up control of one of your largest unmanaged expenses — or are you ready to own your risk strategy?